Who We Are

We are a locally owned independent insurance agency based in southern Maine. We represent a carefully selected group of financially sound, reputable insurance companies.

Why Choose Us

Our agents constantly review our client’s policies to ensure that they are receiving the best coverage at the lowest price for their needs. Additionally, should you ever need to place a claim, we provide our customers with staff dedicated to working with claims adjusters on their behalf. This allows you to focus on what matters most during your time of need.

Finding the right insurance policies for you and your family can be a challenge in today’s crowded market. Click here to read an article by president Josh Fearon.

Request a Quote

Company History

We were incorporated on December 15, 1928 with roots dating back to 1885. We have since grown into one of the largest, independent, full-service insurance agencies in southern Maine, offering home, auto and business insurance as well as employee benefits.

In 2008 two local banks, Saco and Biddeford Savings Institution and Biddeford Savings Bank, joined together to purchase the firm to ensure that the Biddeford/Saco community continued to have access to a locally owned and managed insurance agency.

In 2011, we changed our name from Paquin & Carroll Insurance to P&C Insurance.

In June of 2013 Saco & Biddeford Savings Institution became the sole owner of P&C Insurance. Saco & Biddeford Savings is Maine’s Oldest Bank, founded in 1827.

In January of 2020, we went through a rebranding to strengthen our relationship with our other business lines and to better reflect our core belief: In It Together. We wanted to pay homage to the history of our company, and switched our name back to Paquin & Carroll Insurance.

Get in Touch

Our Team

Josh Fearon, CIC President
Andrea Todd, CIC Vice President - Commercial Lines Account Executive
Lynn Vigneault, CISR Vice President - Personal Lines
Dan Cote Vice President - Employee Benefits
Doug Willett, CIC Vice President - Business Development
Beth Libby Account Manager - Commercial Lines
Bonnie Sawyer Account Manager, Team Leader - Personal Lines
Buffy Cartier Administrative Assistant
Carol Binette, AAI Account Executive, Account Manager - Commercial Lines
Christine Robida Account Manager - Personal Lines
Christine Bowden Account Manager - Commercial Lines
Dave Gash, AAI Commercial Account Executive
Dawn Drown Account Manager - Employee Benefits
Dwayne Welch, CPCU Account Manager – Personal Lines
Jennifer Poulin Account Manager - Personal Lines
Kelli Locke Account Manager - Commercial Lines
Kristen Jenkins Account Manager – Commercial Lines
Lisa Huot Administrative Assistant
Lori Bataran Claims Administrator
Lynnsey McDonough Account Executive - Personal Lines
Meghan McDonald Administrative Account Executive - Employee Benefits
Nicole Goodine Account Manager - Commercial Lines
Patti Chambers Administrative Assistant
Paula Hayward Assistant Account Manager - Employee Benefits
Phillip Smith, CIC Account Executive - Commercial Lines
Raina Bryant Account Manager - Personal Lines
Rob Eastman Account Manager - Personal Lines
Robyn Sukeforth Account Manager – Commercial Lines
Sarah Boudreau Account Manager - Commercial Lines
Teresa Kowalski Account Manager - Commercial Lines
Tom Quentin Account Executive - Accountant
Tori Chapman Account Executive - Employee Benefits

Career Opportunities

Technology and products may have changed over the years, but our focus has not. Our commitment is to maintain the highest standard of service and to establish long term client relationships based on responsibility and mutual trust. Sound appealing?


  • Medical Insurance
  • Dental Insurance
  • Life Insurance
  • Eye Care Reimbursement
  • Long-term disability
  • 401(k) Plan
  • Wellness Allowance
  • Paid Time Off (Vacation, Personal Time, Holidays, Sick Leave)
  • Employee Assistance Program
  • Tuition Reimbursement
  • And More

Current Job Openings

Account Manager - Personal Lines
Learn More About Open Jobs at P&C Insurance and Saco & Biddeford Savings

Employment Disclaimer: Applications will be accepted only for current employment opportunities for which a vacant position is posted at P&C Insurance.

Reasonable Accommodation Request:

Equal access to employment is available to all persons. Those applicants requiring reasonable accommodation to the application process should email careers@insurancepc.com or call 207-284-4591 and ask for the Human Resources Department. Please do not direct any other general employment related questions to this email and/or phone number. Only inquiries concerning a request for a reasonable accommodation will be responded to from this email address and/or phone number.

P &C Insurance is an Equal Opportunity Employer of women, minorities, protected veterans and individuals with disabilities. Please click on the links below to view federally required posters: